CPSIA – Freedom of Information Act Document Request

As submitted today:

To: cpsc-foia@cpsc.gov

Re: Fast Track FOIA Request Relating to Draft House Legislation Known as “Consumer Product Safety Enhancement Act of 2010”

I am making this document request pursuant to the Freedom of Information Act and 16 CFR §1015. I would like to receive copies of all documents (written or electronic, including notes and staff briefing packages) relating to (a) interactions between Chairman Inez Tenenbaum and/or Commissioner Robert Adler and/or their staff and the House Committee on Energy and Commerce (and/or staff associated with that committee or its members) relating to the Consumer Product Safety Enhancement Act (CPSEA), and (b) any CPSC legal analyses or legal opinions relating to the CPSEA. Since the CPSEA is presently being circulated in draft form on Capitol Hill and since the committee’s staff is seeking feedback from various stakeholders at this time, time is of the essence for this information request. Please accord this request “fast track” status.

In making this request, I note the following statement in 16 CFR §1015(b): “The Commission’s policy with respect to requests for records is that disclosure is the rule and withholding is the exception. All records not exempt from disclosure will be made available. Moreover, records which may be exempted from disclosure will be made available as a matter of discretion when disclosure is not prohibited by law or is not against the public interest.”

My contact information is found below. Thank you for your cooperation.

Sincerely,

Richard Woldenberg
Chairman
Learning Resources, Inc.

Read more here:
CPSIA – Freedom of Information Act Document Request

CPSIA – WSJ’s 6th Editorial BASHING the CPSIA

REVIEW & OUTLOOK

NOVEMBER 7, 2009

Congress’s Brass Knuckles
Another casualty of the lead toy ‘safety’ law.

The wheels on the bus won’t go ’round and ’round in many playrooms this year if the Consumer Product Safety Commission has its way. On Wednesday, the Commission voted against a petition to exempt small pieces of brass used in the wheels on toy cars, tractors and buses from draconian lead standards. The fiasco is one more sign that Congress must address the chaos created by its 2008 law regulating lead in toys.

Lead is a typical component of brass but poses minuscule risk to children through toys. As the CPSC’s own staff remarked, “the estimated exposure to lead from children’s contact with the die-cast toys would have little impact on the blood lead level.” But no matter, the language of the law says the Commission can’t consider risk in granting exclusions. Any potential absorption of lead at all is grounds for a ban, despite its presence in other common brass fixtures kids get their hands on regularly, like doorknobs and keys.

Democrats in Congress have insisted that problems with the law they wrote are the fault of the CPSC charged with implementing it. How’s that going? Following the Commission’s 3-2 vote against the brass exemption, CPSC Commissioner Anne Northrop noted that the decision not to grant a brass exemption shows that “the Commission does not believe there is any [flexibility] written into the law.” Without action from Congress to address the chaos it created, Ms. Northrop said, “More small businesses will be forced to shut down.”

CPSC Chairman Inez Tenenbaum has insisted that changing the law would be “premature.” Yet it has already been more than a year of bedlam for manufacturers and retailers negotiating these rules. In February, the CPSC’s one year stay of enforcement on testing will expire, opening the field to more crackdowns on small businesses.

Many of the worst problems were apparent when the bill was written but lawmakers ignored the warnings in order to satisfy Naderite interest groups. Democrats have refused to fix this mess, at great cost to businesses, and further underscoring government’s reputation for unfairness and incompetence.

Read more here:
CPSIA – WSJ’s 6th Editorial BASHING the CPSIA

CPSIA – Trading on Melodrama

From Timothy Carney of The Washington Examiner, in his September 4 opinion piece on the CPSC ill-considered and contemptible “Resale Roundup”: “’Those who re-sell recalled children’s products are not only breaking the law, they are putting children’s lives at risk,’ said CPSC Chairman Inez Tenenbaum. ‘Resale stores should make safety their business and check for recalled products and hazards to children.’” I am not in favor of encouraging the sale of recalled products, but I think this is over-the-top and inexcusable (even for a rookie). In one quote, Ms.

The rest is here:
CPSIA – Trading on Melodrama