CPSIA – Mike Green Attacks Anne Northup in WSJ

In Thursday’s Wall Street Journal, Mike Green of the notorious Center for Environmental Health, a known Proposition 65 bounty hunter, attacked Commissioner Anne Northup for her criticisms of the CPSIA:

“Anne Northup notes that the Consumer Product Safety Improvement Act (CPSIA) passed with bipartisan support, so it is surprising to see her partisan attack on this children’s health protection law (“There Is No Joy in Toyland,” op-ed, Dec. 24). She states that lead in metals used in children’s products is not “bioavailable,” and thus cannot harm children. This will come as a shock to Juanna Graham, whose son died after swallowing a metal charm. At least eight other children have suffered lead poisoning after sucking on or swallowing small lead pieces from toys or jewelry.

Ms. Northup also errs in stating that lead is not absorbable in materials other than paint. Over the past five years we have found high levels of lead in numerous vinyl children’s items, including baby bibs, lunchboxes, rain gear, toys, and others. Independent lab tests showed that lead in these products can wipe off and expose children to unsafe levels of lead.

Michael Green
Executive Director
Center for Environmental Health
Oakland, Calif.”

This is nonsense, of course. It is very important to leave comments on this misleading and manipulative letter at the WSJ.com website. If you click at the link above, you will see a block to leave a comment. I left one and you should, too.

Thank you.

Read more here:
CPSIA – Mike Green Attacks Anne Northup in WSJ

CPSIA – It’s 2010, Our Fourth Year of Travails

I can’t believe it’s 2010. We are now entering the fourth year of the CPSIA mess. The children’s product safety fiasco began in 2007 with large scale lead-in-paint recalls by a limited number of companies. The perceived betrayal of trust was enough to set off an unstoppable legislative tsunami, giving birth to the noxious CPSIA. Today, years later, we find ourselves beleaguered by

1. An inflexible law which is especially penal to small business,
2. A deaf Congress, resolute in its refusal to hold a real, open hearing or to foster debate,
3. A paralyzed CPSC so hobbled by the problems and tasks of the new law that it cannot even meet deadlines with 15 months lead time, and
4. A demoralized manufacturer community, numbed and confused by the process.

On the bright side, Henry Waxman floated a CPSIA amendment last month, apparently publicly conceding that the law needs to be changed and that the CPSC cannot fix the problems by themselves. In addition, the CPSC will be filing its own requests and recommendations on January 15 to satisfy a requirement in its appropriations grant.

Our struggle to foster change is producing results but we are not done. This terrible, distracting journey is not at an end, and we must steel ourselves for more fighting if we want to be governed again with common sense and rationality. So with a hearty Happy New Year, I wish you strength of character and a head of steam for the fight that lays ahead.

I will close this post with a poem by Paul Eldridge published in 1945 entitled “I Bring a Sword”:

To the beasts preying upon my people
To the hyenas mocking their grief
To the hounds barring their gates
To the ostriches burying their heads
To the crocodiles shedding tears
To the snakes hissing malignities
To the monkeys chattering diplomacies
To the asses braying profundities
To the cocks crowing prophecies
To the owls hooting defeat -
I BRING A SWORD!

Let that be our motto for 2010!

Read more here:
CPSIA – It’s 2010, Our Fourth Year of Travails

« Previous Page